Sucker Punch? Fighting in the NHL

There are few subjects more controversial in hockey that fighting. The fact is the stats don't exactly punch you in the face either for or against getting rid of it. Nor does it confirm or deny how successful a team will be. Maple Leafs head coach as always wanted toughness and abrasive play and to his credit the Leafs are a much tougher team to play against than in years past and lead the NHL with 43, 10 more than Philadelphia another organization who favors the old fashioned game. The thing is one of these is a playoff team, barring an epic collapse, and Philly, barring a miracle, isn't. among the other league leaders are Boston, Winnipeg, Vancouver, Columbus and Tampa Bay. Several of these teams are either in the hunt or already have a spot while Tampa well, isn't. At the other end a team in Edmonton who many critics have derided as needing more girt are last with just 13 with one fewer than Detroit's 14. To counter that Chicago only have 16 and are doing just fine.

As I said, I don't have the answers and if they are to be found in the numbers, best of luck! There are those who will analyze the minutes after a shift to see what kind of impact it has and in fairness I've seen first hand on many occasions where it will pump a team up and get a sluggish outing turned around. However I've also seen it back fire by firing up the other team or taking an unnecessary penalty detrimental to the team.

Last nights Sens Hurricanes game was a fight filled affair and many of them were out of frustration but the first was between Jared Cowan and Chad LaRose after Cowan leveled Jeff Skinner, with a huge though clean hit, knocking him out of the game. LaRose gave up about seven inches and a lot of weight but stepped in to defend his teammate. I admire and applaud him for this, even if it didn't work out to his advantage. This is a part of the game that is needed to help police it. I get sick and tired of seeing it after every clean hit but when guys cross the line it's a great tool to help maintain law and order.

That said, I'm not a big fan of the staged fight or having some giant on the bench with hands of stone who's only out there to be a punching bag. I like the flow of the game and there are plenty of players with enough skill and grit to do both and those are the guys I'd want on my third and fourth lines. The main concern of course is injuries and when guys go out of their weight class they can get hurt but fights rarely result in serious injuries and while people argue players need to be protected from themselves it serves a deterrent from guys running around taking cheap shots where the real serious injuries occur. The players themselves see the game changing and I think the roll of the enforcer is slowly dying as the game gets quicker but there is still a place in the game for guys who are willing to drop them, and I say let'em at it.